Skip to main content

GUILTY BY SUSPICION

USA, 1991 (MIFF 1991)

Director: Irwin Winkler

Veteran producer Irwin Winkler makes an assured writing - directing debut with this involving drama about Hollywood professionals affected by the insidious blacklists of the early 1950's, the infamous era of McCarthyism.

One of Winkler's long-time associates, Robert DeNiro, is excellent in a notably unmannered, serenely impassioned performance as David Merrill, who's known as powerful studio head, Darryl F. Zanuck's "golden boy" and returns to the film capital after a break in Europe, only to find the atmosphere in Dream City, taking on the chilling aspects of a steadily spiralling nightmare. Requested by his boss Zanuck to co-operate with the witch-hunting House Un-American Activities Committee, Merrill refuses, even though an associate has already accused him of attending left-wing meetings years before. Almost immediately, Merrill is removed from all current projects, and finds himself in hock and looking for work, any work. Events climax with Merrill's appearance before a full committee in Washington, scenes which reveal HUACs mean-mindedness and evil with powerful accuracy.

Much of the movie's gradually gathering impact stems from placing at the centre of its moral arena a relatively mild-mannered hero, who through youthful "indiscretion", rather than any real conviction, manages to get trapped in McCarthyism's widening snares. The mounting majesty of De Niro's characterisation is ably matched by a solid supporting cast which includes Annette Bening as Merrill's ex-wife and another of Winkler's colleagues, Martin Scorsese, as a filmmaker uncannily reminiscent of real-life blacklist target, director Joseph Losey.

Director's Note: "I thought it was more interesting if the guy wasn't even a communist. That's something you can relate to. If he was a communist, it's too easy for the audience to understand why the HUAC called him up and attacked him. I never wanted it to be a defence of Communism. I wanted it to be a defence of liberty" -Irwin Winkler

See also...

CHANGING OUR MINDS: THE STORY OF DR. EVELYN HOOKER

... ... During the McCarthy era, Dr Evelyn Hook­er took on the moral majority and the American Psychiatric Association (APA) to prove, through a pioneer clinical study, homo­sexuality was ... More »

Dexter on Vacation

Dexter On Vacation records the last perfor­mance of legendary saxophonist Dexter Gor­don aboard the S S Normandy during the 1988 Floating Jazz Festival "When Dexter stood in my studio and ... More »

The Room

"The streets down there are full of sick peo­ple." Dad bars the window and bolts the door against the siege from without, then begins his own siege at home. But as he hammers his son's locked ... More »

PARIS TROUT

... ... If Ann Turner's Celia gave the mistaken impression that it examined the effects of a 1957 rabbit plague on a suburban Melbourne family, you would be forgiven for assuming Paris Trout's ... More »

Low

James Herbert literally breathes life into this masterpiece, which is visually breathtaking, rich in hue and gracefully sensual. (If you have never seen work by him, don't miss this one.) ... More »

THE USUAL

... ... Minneapolis is a place rarely associated with filmmaking. Yet it's unquestionably home sweet home to director, writer and editor Eric Tretbar, who seems to know the territory like the back of ... More »

Select a festival
Search The Film Archive
Browse By Director